NAACP Urges Boycott After University of Florida DEI Cancellation (Ep. 112)
The NAACP urges black student-athletes to boycott the University of Florida in response to the University of Florida cancelling its DEI office. But are black students actually at-risk?
#diversity #equity #naacp #inclusion #counterthought #podcast #news #universityofflorida
----
Remember to Like, Comment and Share this episode.
Remember to SUBSCRIBE to Counter Thought.
----
AUDIO versions of podcast episodes are available on your podcast app.
VIDEO versions of podcast episodes are available on YouTube and Rumble.
YOUTUBE: https://youtu.be/Ls3q2AbFH-A
RUMBLE: https://rumble.com/v4iy3i6-naacp-urges-boycott-after-university-of-florida-dei-cancellation-ep.-112.html
----
FOLLOW Counter Thought on social media:
Instagram: @counter_thought
Instagram: @counterthoughtceo
X (Twitter): @counterceo
TikTok: @counterthought
Facebook: "Counter Thought Podcast" page
Transcript
Welcome to Counter Thought.
2
:A podcast conserving America's
freedom, culture and values.
3
:This is Brian Kletter,
the creator and host of the podcast.
4
:You can engage with the podcast on
Instagram @counter_thought
5
:or @counterthoughtceo,
6
:and on our Facebook page
Counter Thought Podcast.
7
:For audio versions of the podcast,
8
:you can find us on Apple Podcasts,
Google podcasts, Spotify, and more.
9
:And for video versions of the podcast,
10
:join us on YouTube at the Counter
Thought channel.
11
:Let's go.
12
:The University
13
:of Florida, the flagship university
for the state of Florida, made headlines
14
:last week when it completely eliminated
its DEI office.
15
:Now, this week, the NAACP has said that
it is calling on black college student
16
:athletes to reconsider their attendance
at these state universities,
17
:threatening the university system
and Governor DeSantis
18
:and the Florida legislature
19
:saying that the removal of this office
and Senate Bill 266,
20
:which was signed into law last year,
threatens
21
:the education of minorities.
22
:But is that really the case?
23
:Welcome to Counter Thought.
24
:On Monday of this week,
it was reported by ESPN that the NAACP
25
:has asked black student athletes
in the state of Florida to reconsider
26
:their attendance of these college colleges
and universities in response
27
:to the elimination of the DEI office
28
:at the University of Florida.
29
:Now, the history of this decision
by the University of Florida goes back
30
:to last year in May, when governor
when the Florida legislature,
31
:sent Senate Bill SB 266
32
:to Governor
DeSantis desk for signing into law
33
:and that bill was signed by DeSantis.
34
:And what that law does
35
:is that law actually says that it is,
36
:“prohibits institutions
37
:from spending federal or state dollars
on discriminatory initiatives
38
:such as the so called diversity
equity and inclusion
39
:DEI programs.”
40
:Now, DEI has been in the news
41
:for quite some time,
for a few years, actually.
42
:But last year, the Florida legislature
and Governor
43
:DeSantis, DeSantis passed the law
44
:saying that the state of Florida,
45
:its colleges and universities
and the University of Florida is
46
:the foremost
is the flagship university in the state
47
:to eliminate these programs.
48
:So right off the bat,
the outrage at the University
49
:of Florida is really misplaced.
50
:The University of Florida is just
in compliance with the law of the state.
51
:But those like Emmitt
52
:Smith,
you may have heard what he had to say.
53
:Do not believe that that is a good enough
excuse
54
:because Emmitt Smith
55
:believes
that there should be a protest of sorts,
56
:that these black college student
athletes should be on high alert
57
:because of what the University of Florida
has done, that the University of Florida
58
:cannot just wiggle its way
out of its responsibility by saying that
59
:it is, you know,
just remaining in compliance with
60
:with the law.
61
:And Emmitt Smith, you may not know,
62
:is a college football hall of Famer.
63
:He is in the University of Florida's
football ring of honor.
64
:He is also a NFL Hall of Famer.
65
:He was the leading rusher in all of NFL
66
:history, played for the Dallas
Cowboys, won three NFL championships.
67
:So his
voice carries some some weight to it.
68
:He is a legend in college and in the NFL.
69
:And he said, “I am utterly disgusted
70
:by UF’s decision
and the precedent that it sets.
71
:Without the department, the job falls
to the office of the provost,
72
:who already has their hands full
to raise money for the university
73
:and continues to advanced academic studies
and athletic programs.
74
:We cannot continue to believe and trust
75
:that the team of leaders
all made up of the same background
76
:will make the right decision
77
:when it comes to equality and diversity.
78
:History has already proven
that is not the case.”
79
:He continues, “Instead of showing
courage and leadership,
80
:we continue to fail
based on systemic issues.
81
:And with this decision, UF has conformed
to the political pressures
82
:of today's time.”
83
:So Emmitt Smith is not mincing words
84
:in response to his university's decision.
85
:Now, one thing
I don't really agree with within
86
:its statement is the fact that there
needs, the belief that there needs to be
87
:a DEI office to take something off
the plate of the provost.
88
:The University of Florida has done
a fantastic job in the last
89
:10 to 15 years of elevating the university
90
:from a top 20, top 25 public school
when I was in attendance there.
91
:I attended from 2004 to 2008
92
:and the mission there under President
93
:Bernie Machin was to get Florida
94
:to be a top 10 public university.
95
:And we accomplished that.
96
:And then the next president,
97
:Kent Fuchs,
98
:had the goal of getting Florida
to a top five public university
99
:and achieved that.
100
:And his term as president ended,
101
:I believe, two years ago.
102
:And now Ben Sasse is the current president
103
:of the University of Florida.
104
:So Florida, before this
105
:DEI program,
was already achieving success.
106
:And it wasn't because they were sitting
here and only admitting white students
107
:and some would even say white
and Asian American students.
108
:No, they continued to bring in
109
:people
who deserve to be there on the merits.
110
:And sure,
there are still scholarship out there
111
:that are awarded private scholarships
that are given to individuals.
112
:I received a scholarship
from a gator club.
113
:There are other scholarships through,
114
:you know, different companies
and different clubs that support
115
:and advocate for minorities
to go to college.
116
:Like there's there's no issue with that.
117
:But what the Senate
118
:bill this this bill, SB 266
that was signed into law
119
:in May of last year by Governor DeSantis,
120
:it's similar and kind of in step, in line,
121
:with the Supreme Court decision
also in last year, also last year
122
:regarding affirmative action.
123
:The Supreme Court ruled 6 to 3
124
:and overturned and eliminated
125
:affirmative action.
126
:When it comes to
127
:colleges and universities,
128
:the case
before them at the time was a case
129
:involving
University of North Carolina and Harvard,
130
:saying that they were unlawfully
131
:because you cannot discriminate based on,
you know, religion, ethnicity,
132
:race,
133
:gender, all of these things.
134
:You cannot discriminate based upon that
135
:the country,
136
:the government cannot discriminate
based upon those things.
137
:And it was found in that case
138
:that these universities
were actually doing so.
139
:So the Supreme
140
:Court struck down affirmative action,
saying like it is time for this to end.
141
:A Supreme Court
in the affirmative action had been
142
:had been in place
for four decades at the time.
143
:And you go back and Sandra Day O'Connor,
he ruled on, I believe it was:
144
:case, stated that affirmative action
really only needed
145
:a lifeline, a lifetime of about 25 years
146
:from that date.
147
:And that 25 years is has come.
148
:Has it has it has arrived
149
:in affirmative action,
had great intentions.
150
:Affirmative action was a way to to catch
151
:black Americans up
for all of the discrimination
152
:that they've faced for over 100 years.
153
:All of that discrimination,
all of those setbacks.
154
:Again, going back
to, you know, legitimate racism,
155
:putting the thumb on the scale
156
:so that they could not get ahead.
157
:But this DEI program and this is not
just at the university level.
158
:This is also when companies
I come from the corporate world
159
:and I have seen DEI put into place
at at companies and discussed in actually
160
:in the current job market, witnessing
this DEI
161
:is basically a veil
162
:to disguise
163
:discriminatory hiring practices.
164
:Much like affirmative action
165
:had good intent, DEI,
166
:in its truest form,
167
:also has good intentions.
168
:You want there to be diversity.
169
:You want there to be inclusion.
170
:You don't want to exclude people.
171
:You want people to feel welcomed.
172
:You want diversity, you want
you want everyone to look the same.
173
:You don't want everyone to think the same.
174
:But people have
175
:turned it to become a way to,
176
:you know, achieve the outcomes, right,
which is equity.
177
:And I talked about equity,
I believe it was episode
178
:two of this podcast somewhere
between in the first five episodes.
179
:Go back and listen. It's an audio only.
180
:I talked about equity versus equality.
181
:Equality
means that you have the same opportunity
182
:to succeed, which I believe, and I stated
in that episode that I believe
183
:in, that there should be equality
starting with your childhood.
184
:Every child should have
an equal opportunity and a good education.
185
:But equity
186
:is about equal outcomes
187
:and you cannot guarantee equal outcomes.
188
:Everyone is different.
189
:Everyone has different skill sets,
190
:everyone has different drives
and desires, different circumstances.
191
:You can have twins, right?
192
:Twin children who grew up in the same
household and have different lives.
193
:They are not
194
:both going to become,
you know, have the same profession,
195
:even just siblings, brother, brother,
sister, sister, brother, sister,
196
:growing up in the same household
are not going to go on
197
:and do the same things.
198
:So when it comes back to DEI,
199
:it is a way to to give an advantage
to promote
200
:and hire or promote
201
:people
202
:who fit a certain requirement.
203
:That is
204
:the that is what DEI is being used
205
:for in a lot of cases.
206
:And what tickles me,
207
:what made me laugh
whenever actually, you know,
208
:whenever I read the statement
209
:from the NAACP
210
:saying that,
211
:you know, because of this decision
by the University of Florida
212
:and the law in general
by the state of Florida
213
:calling on black athletes to threaten
214
:openly threaten the
215
:universities, to withdraw themselves
from the universities
216
:or to go and play elsewhere, saying that
217
:black athletes are,
218
:you know,
that the education of black athletes,
219
:that this might be the only way for them
to actually receive a higher education.
220
:Let me
221
:let me read this this to you.
222
:Black student
223
:athletes should reconsider
attending public colleges and universities
224
:in Florida,
said the NAACP president, Charlie Baker,
225
:on Monday, March 11th,
226
:says, “This is not about politics.
227
:It's about the protection
of our community, the progression
228
:of our culture, and most of all, it's
about your education and your future.”
229
:It goes on, “While
it is our duty to spread awareness
230
:and encourage action
around these egregious assaults,
231
:we also recognize that
protests can come at a price.
232
:The sad,
233
:sad reality is for many black student
athletes,
234
:collegiate sports
may be their sole opportunity at achieving
235
:the upward mobility necessary
to propel them into their rightful places
236
:in society.”
237
:“Florida's rampant
238
:anti-black policies are a direct threat
to the advancement
239
:of our young people in their ability
240
:to compete in a global economy.
241
:Diversity, equity and inclusion
242
:are paramount to ensuring equitable
in effective educational outcomes.
243
:The value black
244
:and other college athletes bring to large
universities is unmatched.
245
:If their institutions are unable
to completely invest in those athletes,
246
:it's time to take their talents
elsewhere.”
247
:In that last statement,
248
:“If these institutions are unable
to completely invest
249
:in those athletes, it's
time to take their talents
250
:elsewhere.”
251
:Now, the argument that the NAACP is making
is stating that because of the like,
252
:for example, this and this is a response
to the University of Florida,
253
:that because the University of Florida
has eliminated the DEI office,
254
:they are
making it seem, they want you to believe
255
:that the current black student
athletes at the University of Florida
256
:are not going to receive the education
that they would have received
257
:through that DEI office.
258
:Mind you, the DEI office
at the University of Florida
259
:didn't exist until a few years ago.
260
:And the University of Florida
has been around
261
:since 1853.
262
:You know,
263
:black students, black student
athletes have been there
264
:for decades.
265
:Right? Decades.
266
:We're talking about 60 years or so.
267
:And there was never a DEI office
268
:going back to 60 years ago,
269
:never a DEI office.
270
:Yet, You know,
these black student athletes for 60 years,
271
:six decades, still received a quality
272
:education.
273
:So they're trying to get it twisted
274
:and confuse people.
275
:Confuse you, confuse me, confuse
the black student athletes to lead them
276
:to believe that they are no longer
going to receive the proper counseling
277
:for the advancement of their education.
278
:Now, in my time at University of Florida,
279
:I worked for the University
Athletic Association.
280
:That is the separate entity
that is in charge of all of the athletics
281
:college athletes
at the university of Florida.
282
:And do you know what the University
Athletic Association has?
283
:Tutors.
284
:Tutors.
285
:They have tutors.
286
:They have counselors.
287
:These student athletes,
whether you are black,
288
:white, Latino, Asian, whatever,
289
:regardless of your race, your nationality,
you have access
290
:to these resources.
291
:Student
athletes at the University of Florida,
292
:because it is a perennial top five
athletic program,
293
:have more access to resources
294
:than your standard college student.
295
:But the NAACP wants you
296
:to believe that that is not the case.
297
:And what's even
298
:funnier,
and this is really what tickled me
299
:is that to
300
:become a student athlete, a college
student athlete, you have to receive
301
:You are being awarded,
whether it's a scholarship,
302
:a partial scholarship, walking
on, you know, no scholarship received.
303
:You are there and on a team
304
:because of merit,
because of your skill set.
305
:You are not there to check a box.
306
:You are there because you have an advanced
level of skill to play at the college
307
:level and the University of Florida
as a top five perennial
308
:top five program in all of college
athletics
309
:is not checking a box
by giving you a scholarship or
310
:or saying
that you can be a part of a team.
311
:So the NAACP
312
:is trying to make the college
black college
313
:student athlete at the University
of Florida and other state schools.
314
:The University of Florida,
where they're also receiving scholarships
315
:because of merit and their skill set.
316
:They are arguing
317
:that because they're trying to confuse you
318
:to make it seem
as if merit was not being rewarded
319
:as to why those black student athletes
320
:are at the school in the first place.
321
:And like I just said, with the resources,
322
:the University of Florida
gives more resources to student athletes
323
:than your general standard student
at the University of Florida.
324
:There are a few hundred student
athletes at the University of Florida,
325
:and there are dozens of counselors and
326
:and tutors available to them.
327
:You know, the ratio,
if I had to guess a ballpark,
328
:is probably like 1 to 25.
329
:There are about 40,000 45,000
330
:students at the University of Florida,
331
:and there are definitely not 2000 tutors
332
:and advisers on staff
at the University of Florida.
333
:But the
334
:NAACP is trying to get the black student
athletes
335
:to threaten the university
to pull their their skills and ultimately,
336
:you know, affect the bottom line,
the money, the revenue
337
:that these athletic programs bring in
338
:to try to get the university
to defy the law for the state
339
:and bring back the DEI office.
340
:But this is right in line with the NAACP
does.
341
:You may remember that the NAACP
342
:going back to last year,
343
:said that the state of Florida
is, “unsafe”
344
:for black Americans,
345
:unsafe.
346
:And you may remember
347
:the hilarity of it all
because the NAACP president
348
:was living in Tampa at the time.
349
:Tampa, if you are unaware,
350
:is a major city in the state of Florida.
351
:And he's saying, the state of Florida is
352
:is unsafe for for for blacks,
that you are no longer, that you are not
353
:welcomed in the state of Florida,
which is foolishness.
354
:They they
they instituted a travel advisory.
355
:I have it.
I have it right here in front of me.
356
:I will read it to
357
:you, “Under its current governor,
358
:the state of Florida has engaged
in an all out attack on black Americans,
359
:accurate black history, voting rights,
members of the LGBTQ community,
360
:immigrants, women's reproductive rights,
free speech, while simultaneously
361
:embracing a culture of fear, bullying,
intimidation
362
:by public officials.”
363
:And then it goes on,
364
:“Under
the leadership of Governor Ron DeSantis,
365
:the state of Florida has criminalized
protests, restricted abilities,
366
:the ability of educators
to teach African-American history
367
:and engage in a blatant war
against diversity and inclusion.
368
:Please be advised that Florida is openly
369
:hostile, openly hostile
370
:toward African-Americans, people of color
371
:and LGBTQ plus individuals.
372
:Before traveling
373
:to Florida,
374
:please understand that the state
of Florida devalues and marginalizes
375
:the contributions of in the challenges
faced by African-Americans and
376
:other minorities.”
377
:And then it goes on to,
378
:please be advised,
public schools...yada yada yada.
379
:So this call by the NAACP
380
:in response to the University of Florida
eliminating the DEI office
381
:and saying that in asking
the black student athletes to threaten
382
:to leave the university or if they are,
would be an incoming recruiting class
383
:to not attend the University of Florida
or other state schools
384
:is right in line with that travel advisory
that the NAACP issued last year.
385
:While they, literally,
while the president of the NAACP
386
:was literally living in Tampa.
387
:And I'm sure his reasoning was like,
you know, I'll be the one to fall
388
:on the sword, right?
389
:I'll be the one to stay behind and
390
:and live over here in beautiful Tampa
while the rest of you,
391
:you know, flee the state or,
you know, don't even want to come here.
392
:But this
393
:DEI elimination by the state of Florida,
394
:again, is similar to affirmative action,
395
:is similar to the affirmative action
ruling
396
:going back to last year.
397
:And the Supreme Court struck down those
affirmative action programs in colleges
398
:6 to 3, but left the door open for race
to be considered.
399
:But not just because, hey,
400
:X race,
401
:but in the telling of a story
of how your race
402
:impacted your upbringing
403
:and how you overcame it,
404
:there was a door open there.
405
:But by a 6 to 3 decision,
the Supreme Court
406
:eliminated affirmative action.
407
:And Chief Justice John Roberts
explained that college admission
408
:programs can consider race merely
to allow an applicant to explain
409
:how their race influence their character
in a way that would have a concrete
410
:effect on the university.
411
:But a
412
:student must be treated based on his
or her experience as an individual,
413
:not on the basis of race.
414
:That is what Chief Justice Roberts wrote.
415
:DEI, again,
416
:has good intentions.
417
:It sounds great.
418
:Diversity? Yes.
419
:You want the best outcomes for people?
420
:Fairness? Sure.
421
:Inclusion, not exclusionary one? Yes.
422
:But it is as well intended as it sounds.
423
:It is not being utilized that way.
424
:It is not being implemented that way.
425
:And this is at universities.
426
:This is at companies,
especially major corporations.
427
:I'm currently going through a job hunting
process and every single application
428
:I submit has every job requisition
and then every application
429
:has a DEI statement and DEI questions.
430
:Most of them also state
431
:that they have to ask these questions
because of a federal
432
:law or mandate.
433
:And you're going to have a hard time
convincing me,
434
:especially because the federal government
is involved,
435
:that your selections on these applications
436
:are not impacting
437
:where you are slotted on the rankings of
438
:for interviews and potential job offers.
439
:If you want to know all this information,
this information
440
:is being utilized
and it's not being utilized just to count
441
:and and analyze who's applying
for what position.
442
:There are companies out there
443
:who are using DEI
and promoting individuals
444
:based on their race or their ethnicity
445
:or their gender, their sex.
446
:So DEI is not being used
447
:for good.
448
:We need to get back to merits
in this country.
449
:The argument
one of the arguments about eliminating
450
:affirmative action,
about eliminating, eliminating DEI,
451
:these diversity hires.
452
:Remember, we heard about it
a lot with Ketanji Brown Jackson
453
:can also say that was the same thing
for Trump's
454
:appointment with Amy Coney Barrett,
a woman.
455
:Right?
456
:Kamala Harris, woman.
457
:You know, Biden said
that he was going to do that, have a woman
458
:vice president and went ahead and did it.
459
:We need to get back to to merit.
460
:And one of the arguments against,
461
:you know, making a diversity hire,
462
:whether it be at the government or a
private company, is that you immediately.
463
:And Clarence Thomas talks about this.
464
:You immediately undercut that individual
465
:saying, they only have the position
466
:because of their race,
because of their gender,
467
:because of their sexuality,
their ethnicity.
468
:You immediately undercut them.
469
:And I wish
470
:more people and maybe it's
because of the level
471
:that they're being hired at, the power
that they have, the clout that they have,
472
:that they would be
that they would not be okay
473
:with being hired and being
and having that associated with them.
474
:Of “you were just a diversity hire.”
475
:I would get sick and tired
of hearing that.
476
:You know,
477
:if someone was like,
I'm only going to hire this guy over here.
478
:And I had that quality
and I was the one that was hired,
479
:I would get sick and tired of being told
that I only have that position
480
:not because I am capable of that position,
481
:not because of what I accomplished
to earn that position,
482
:but because of something that
has completely, absolutely nothing to do
483
:with your position,
484
:with your accolade.
485
:So we as the people
486
:I think, are going to have to start
swallowing some pride here
487
:and demanding that we that this
this treatment
488
:and as much as a company
or whomever wants to say, you are
489
:you are the first this,
you are the first, that
490
:if that's true, great.
491
:But me personally, I would not really want
something like that attached to me
492
:if it's just going to undercut me
in my accomplishment.
493
:We need to get back to merits and again,
go back to Clarence Thomas.
494
:He talks about,
you know, if and this has been
495
:this has been seen in college admissions,
496
:the lowering of standards
for different races.
497
:We have heard about that,
especially when it comes to applications
498
:and acceptance
at Harvard. You know, Asian-Americans
499
:have to have like the the highest S.A.T.
500
:rate ranking score
and then whites and blacks.
501
:And it's it's different
for different levels of race.
502
:And then as you're admitting people
who are scoring
503
:lower than what they need to score
to actually attend there,
504
:you know, you're giving them
a little bit of a handicap.
505
:And then those individual struggle
at the university
506
:is because they were not
put in a good situation to succeed.
507
:They could have gone to a school that was
more suited for their for their scores
508
:and excelled at those schools
509
:and then got a better job
and worked their way up
510
:through their career path to still attain
511
:the same levels of success.
512
:But it is nothing
513
:new that the NAACP came out and is,
514
:you know, sensationalizing this decision
by the University of Florida.
515
:And that money is going to be,
you know, it is earmarked,
516
:it is going to be used to do similar
things, is what the DEI office was doing.
517
:But it is not going to be
there is no more DEI office.
518
:We, as the people
519
:need to get back to
and as a country as a whole,
520
:get back to rewarding
people based upon merit.
521
:And will some things seem unfair? Yes.
522
:If you analyze statistics
about who's being admitted or
523
:given certain
kind of jobs based on merit alone, is that
524
:are there going to be
is a correlation or causation?
525
:Right.
526
:I know those are that discussion
is going to exist and you'll have people
527
:who will believe it is causation
and people who believe it is correlation.
528
:But I firmly believe that if we go
529
:based off of merit,
530
:if we go based off of merit,
531
:then ultimately in due time
532
:we will everyone will achieve
533
:greater levels
534
:of success, not only in today's generation
535
:in the workforce,
but future generations to come.
536
:Thank
you for listening to Counter Thought.
537
:A podcast conserving America's
freedom, culture and values.
538
:Remember to subscribe and like or rate
539
:the podcast on your podcast app
or on YouTube and engage with the podcast
540
:on Instagram @counter_thought, @counterthoughtceo
541
:or on Facebook at Counter Thought Podcast.